Reply to post

Union Pacific's B-17

Author
donstrack
Cadet
  • Total Posts : 5
  • Reward points : 632
  • Joined:
  • Status: offline
0

Union Pacific's B-17


 
http://utahrails.net/images/up_b-17_Spirit_of_UP.jpg
 
The above link will take you to a photo of a B-17 lettered for "Spirit of the Union Pacific". The photo was taken on August 3, 1943. The names and job titles of the people in the photo make me believe the photo was taken at the Boeing plant in Seattle.
 
The men in the photo are, left to right: H. O. West, executive vice president, Boeing Aircraft Company; Walter Wilson, chairman Union Pacific War Bond Committee; F. W. Madden, representing Brotherhood Railway Clerks; John D. Bear, Brotherhood Maintenance of Way Employes; L. A. Collins, superintendent Oregon Division; D. W. Hood, Brotherhood Railway Trainmen and Arthur A. Murphy, assistant to president, Union Pacific.
 
In a follow-up news item in the September 1945 issue of Union Pacific's employee magazine, there was the following item:
 
"FATE OF U. P. BOMBER NOW REVEALED
 
"Omaha, Nebr.— With the war over, Union Pacific employes now can know the story of the B-17 bomber named in their honor—"The Spirit of Union Pacific."
 
"Back in 1943, the 65,000 employes of the railroad during May and June voluntarily increased their war bond purchases by an extra $379,000, in appreciation were given the privilege of christening a Flying Fortress.
 
"According to information recently released by the War Department "The Spirit of Union Pacific" was on her fifth mission when shot down October 10, 1943, in a raid on enemy installations at Munster, Germany.
 
"Most of the crew were taken prisoner, including the pilot, Capt. Robert B. Short of Los Angeles, a West Point graduate and former native of Norfolk, Neb. Others who parachuted to safety were Lt. Bud H. Hinckley of Rigby, Idaho, the co-pilot; Lt. Stolian, the bombardier; and Sgts. William M. Esseltine, Syracuse, N. Y.; Donald Armstrong, Binghamton, N. Y.; Frank Beckay, Cleveland, 0.; and Eugene A. Runser, Erie, Pa.
 
"The navigator, Lt. Hal K. Hughes of Dallas, Tex., and Sgts. Donald Lowrie, Hazelton, Pa., and Richard Grace, Glassport, Pa., were reported killed."
 
Here is a link to an image of the article.
 
http://utahrails.net/images/up_b-17_follow-up.jpg
 
Based on this information, I've spent some time researching the airplane and the mission, but without much luck.
 
It appears that October 10, 1943 was one of the worst days for the loss of B-17 airplanes and crews, all during what has become known as "Black Week", which included the raid on the ball bearing factories at Schweinfurt.
 
I found a web site for the 100th Bomber Group that includes a listing of the 13 planes lost by that group over Munster on October 10, 1943. Of those 13 aircraft, two crews lost three men as killed in action. The planes were "Lena" aircraft 42-3433 LN-W, and "Slightly Dangerous" aircraft 42-30734 EP-G.
 
But these crew names don't match the news article. I found another reference that 8th Air Force put up 313 aircraft on that day for the raid on Munster.
 
I found a discussion group about the Munster raid, with one message stating that during "Black Week" at least 141 B-17s lost over the continent between October 8 thru 14, 1943. Twenty-seven lost on October 8; twenty-four lost on October 9; thirty lost on October 10; Sixty lost on October 14.
 
This means that of the 30 aircraft lost by the 8th Air Force on October 10, 1943, 13 aircraft came from the 100th BG alone in the raid over Munster.
 
John Bromley, curator at the Union Pacific museum in Council Bluffs, Iowa, wrote the following:
 
"As a side note about the bomber apparently this is not the plane originally intended to be the UP plane. The Army didn't want to wait on the plane for a ceremony so this a second plane that was lettered. In the haste to get it painted they omitted the word "employees." According to Army and Treasury Department instructions on naming bombers, they were supposed to be named for employees of organizations. They didn't want to delay delivery of this plane so it went out as shown. Reportedly it took off immediately after the photo session. This was recorded as the first named heavy bomber recognizing a railroad group."
 
If anyone can add to the above, I'd like to hear from you. Especially if you can help me find the aircraft number.
 
Don Strack
http://utahrails.net/ 
Lucky Partners
Division Member
  • Total Posts : 2197
  • Reward points : 6403
  • Joined:
  • Location: Florida
  • Status: offline
Re:Union Pacific's B-17 (permalink)
0
Don,

Very interesting story.  Based on the info you provided the Short crew was with the 390th Bomb Group and were lost with 42-30826 on October 10, 1943.  The Missing Air Crew Report is posted on Footnote.com and includes statements by the surviving crew men.  Attached are the first two pages of that MACR.  Interestingly there was an 11th man on board that day, no indication in the MACR as to why there were 11.  Click on the thumbnail to enlarge images.

Hal

Attached Image(s)

martyjhawk
Wing Member
  • Total Posts : 985
  • Reward points : 6734
  • Joined:
  • Status: offline
Re:Union Pacific's B-17 (permalink)
0
There are copies of this photo available on ebay.  They are supposedly wartime printed postcards.  Thanks for posting the information on the plane, as I was wondering what the serial of the plane was as well, and if the names of the crew members were correct, then it looks like Hal has identified the plane.   However, according to Forman's B-17 name directory, 42-30826 was named "Short Stuff".  He also has another plane with the name Short Stuff from the same group and squadron (390 BG, 571 BS) so his reference to 42-30826 being named Short Stuff may just be an error.
 
Marty
Lucky Partners
Division Member
  • Total Posts : 2197
  • Reward points : 6403
  • Joined:
  • Location: Florida
  • Status: offline
Re:Union Pacific's B-17 (permalink)
0
Don & Marty,

We have a SLIGHT problem here.  I just checked the 390th BG web site and they show that this a/c was named Short Stuff.  The crew in the MACR matches Don's crew list and agrees with what is posted at the 390th but no mention of The Spirit of the Union Pacific.  Roger Freeman also shows Short Stuff and the MACR with the Short crew.  Name makes sense, pilot named Short, a/c named Short Stuff.  Perhaps the original newspaper story listed the wrong crew??  Could the name have been changed somewhere along the line??  Back to square one.

Hal
jpeters140
Moderator
  • Total Posts : 7043
  • Reward points : 19481
  • Joined:
  • Location: Columbus, Indiana
  • Status: online
Re:Union Pacific's B-17 (permalink)
0
Hal...If the aircraft was damaged enough to be sent to the depot for repair, sometimes the aircraft, when the repair was accomplished, would be assigned to another group...in addition as a crew that originally named the aircraft was rotated to the US on completion of their tour, another crew would change the name/nose art.

When an entire bomb group departed enmasse, the aircraft were named in many cases...and some aircraft were re-assigned on arrival at an overseas destination...this happened to the 483rd BG in the MED....the new aircraft were given to the 99th BG and the 2nd BG,  and traded for older aircraft.

When the 97th departed England for N.Africa for operation "Torch" ..the Invasion of N.Africa, the 97th "E"s were traded for the 92nd's "'F"s...and at the same time, the 92nd was removed from combat, and assigned the job of training the replacement aircrews as they arrived in England....later on in the war, the 92nd resumed combat operations.

Col Lemay was distressed when he attempted to get his aircraft returned from the depot, and he felt that the depot was working Mon-Fri...and he was fighting the war....this had to have had a bearing when he was in charge of SAC...a SAC unit was organized so that the Base Commander reported to the Wing Commander..the only exception was if the SAC Wing was a tenant on the base...otherwise, if the base was totally SAC, the Base Commander reported to the SAC Wing Commander.

Jim :-)

James S. Peters Sr. T/Sgt B-17 Flt Engr, 27 missions 99 BG, 348BS, 5th Wing, 15th AAF Tortorella, (Foggia#2), Italy My Tour was from 12/03/44-06/19/45 M/Sgt USAF (Retired)
donstrack
Cadet
  • Total Posts : 5
  • Reward points : 632
  • Joined:
  • Status: offline
Re:Union Pacific's B-17 (permalink)
0
Based on what Hal and Marty wrote, I did some additional on-line research. I'm going to go with the following information, since the timeline makes sense that 42-30826 was "Spirit of the Union Pacific" while on the ground at Seattle, but was very likely renamed to "Short Stuff" upon becoming Robert Short's aircraft.
 
It had  a very short life: accepted on July 30, 1943 at Boeing at Seattle, painted with Union Pacific lettering on or about August 3, 1943, first flown in theatre on September 9, 1943, and shot down on October 10, 1943.
 
Model: B-17F
Production Block: 120
Manufacturer: BO
Serial Number: 230826
Aircraft Letter: R
Aircraft Name: Short Stuff
Squadron: 571
History: Accepted by USAAF 30 Jul 43. Dallas Mod Center 4 Aug 43. Gore Field 5 Aug 43. Dallas 8 Aug 43. Dalhart 17 Aug 43. Grand Island 3 Sep 43. 8th AF 9 Sep 43. MIA Munster 10 Oct 43. Shot down by fighters, crashed at Ostbevern. Grace, Lowrie KIA, rest POW.
Missing Air Crew Report (MACR): 863
Source: http://www.390th.org/resources/aircraft-assigned-list/
 
Comparing the MACR (all 31 pages), the 390th web site, and Joe Baugher's site suggests that at the time the crew thought the #3 engine had been hit by flak and caught fire. But the cause was later to be found to have been a successful attack by a German Bf-109.
 
30826 (390th BG, 571st BS, "Short Stuff") shot down by Obfw Leo-Lothar Barann in Bf 109G-6 at Ostbevern, Germany Oct 10, 1943.  MACR 863.  2 KIA, 9 POW (http://www.joebaugher.com/usaf_serials/1942_2.html)
 
390th flew out of Framlingham, England; a total of 300 missions were flown, with 144 aircraft being lost
 
390th Bomb Group (Heavy), activated on February 23, 1943
8th Air Force, 4th Bomb Wing, 3rd Air Division
390th BG tail code was "Square J" (3rd Air Division was "Square")
 
After several other searches in various 390th and 571st sites, I found that aircraft code was DI-R. I wanted to find this just in case I run across an unidentfied photo. Although, I think a photo of "Short Stuff" 42-30826 DI-R would be very, very rare.
 
Thanks for you help. This may end up as an article in the magazine of the Union Pacific Historical Society, and on my web site.
 
Don Strack
http://utahrails.net/
Lucky Partners
Division Member
  • Total Posts : 2197
  • Reward points : 6403
  • Joined:
  • Location: Florida
  • Status: offline
Re:Union Pacific's B-17 (permalink)
0
Don,

One more thought.  Your photo shows the name painted on the starboard side.  Most often nose art was painted on the port side.  Could be this a/c had a split personality, Spirit of The Union Pacific on one side and Short Stuff on the other.

Hal
donstrack
Cadet
  • Total Posts : 5
  • Reward points : 632
  • Joined:
  • Status: offline
Re:Union Pacific's B-17 (permalink)
0
I thought I'd update this thread. I have completed the article about the Union Pacific B-17. The article is on my web site, and includes a link to several photos that were shared with me by Capt Short's son, including a couple of both sides of "Short Stuff." Capt Short wrote that his aircraft was out of service, and he and his crew were flying the Union Pacific plane for the mission over Munster.
 
http://utahrails.net/up/up-b-17.php
 
Don Strack
patootie
Group Member
  • Total Posts : 215
  • Reward points : 3288
  • Joined:
  • Status: offline
Re:Union Pacific's B-17 (permalink)
0
Hi Don
 
Many thanks for your post
 
very good and interesting research
 
Daniel
Terveurn
Group Member
  • Total Posts : 251
  • Reward points : 1702
  • Joined:
  • Status: offline
Re:Union Pacific's B-17 (permalink)
0
42-30826 (c/n: 5940) Accepted: 30 July 1943 - Boeing Aircraft Co, Seattle, Washington
                (Spirit of the Union Pacific)
                Delivered: 4 August 1943 - Air Technical Service Command / San Antonio Air Depot (SAAD) sub depot - (Hensley AAF)       
                Assigned: 5 August 1943 - ATC / 7th Ferrying Group - (Gore Field)
                                Aircraft Stored
                Assigned: 8 August 1943 - ATC / 5th Ferrying Group - (Love Field)        
                Assigned: 17 August 1943 - 2nd AF / 333rd BG (RTU) - (Dalhart AAF)
                                Replacement crew training - no specific unit assigned
                Assigned: 3 September 1943 - 2nd AF / 17th BTW / 518 HQABSQ (Pilot Training - 4 Engine) - (Grand Island AAF)
                                Replacement crew training - no specific unit assigned
                Assigned: 9 September 1943 - 8th AF / 4th BW / 402nd CBW (P) / 390th BG / 571st BS - (RAF Framlingham)
                                (Square-J) (FC * R / Short Stuff )
                                4 combat missions
                Assigned: 13 September 1943 - 8th AF / 3rd BD / 13th CBW / 390th BG / 571st BS - (RAF Framlingham)
                                MIA: Sunday, 10 October 1943 @ 1500 hrs (Flak / Fighters - Fw190A) - Munster (along Schiffahrter Damm), North Rhine Westphalia - Germany (52°0'17"N / 7°40'24"E)
                                                (Pilot: Capt Robert B Short) - 3 KIA, 7 POW (MACR 863) - SOC
                                                                8th AF mission: 114 / 390th BG mission: 21 (Münster, Germany - Marshaling yard & Canal)(1503 - 1518 hrs)
                                                            Shot down by Uffz. Herzog - 2./JG 1 (I Gruppe) - (Deelen A/D)(HQ87 / 05 Ost S (3.75 miles NE Münster) 7.500 m. @ 1506 hrs)(Anerk 42)
                                                                                                Luftwaffe report KU 348
donstrack
Cadet
  • Total Posts : 5
  • Reward points : 632
  • Joined:
  • Status: offline
Re:Union Pacific's B-17 (permalink)
0
Thanks for the nice summary. I have corrected the aircraft code from DI-R to FC-R.
http://utahrails.net/up/up-b-17.php
For the Munster mission on October 10, 1943, Captain Short's aircraft 42-30332, "Short Stuff," was out of service, so Captain Short and his crew flew aircraft 42-30826, "Spirit of the Union Pacific" instead. Later, and because he had been shot down, his original airplane 42-30332 "Short Stuff" was assigned to a new crew and renamed to "Spirit of '76". It flew until being hit by enemy flak over Orienburg (near Berlin) on April 18, 1944. The aircraft was losing fuel so they turned toward the north coast of Germany. They successfully landed at Bulltofta, Sweden and the crew all returned to duty in October and November 1944. There is no additional information as to the disposition of aircraft 42-30332.
Prior to his death in 1998, Captain Short used "Shortstuff" as his email address.
Don Strack
http://utahrails.net/
Terveurn
Group Member
  • Total Posts : 251
  • Reward points : 1702
  • Joined:
  • Status: offline
Re:Union Pacific's B-17 (permalink)
0
42-30332 (c/n: 5446). Accepted: 14 May 1943 - Boeing Aircraft Co, Seattle, Washington
                Delivered: 4 April 1943 - United Airlines / Boeing Modification Center #10 - (Cheyenne Municipal Airport)
                Assigned: 17 May 1943 - ATC / 7th Ferrying Group - (Gore Field)
                Assigned: 20 May 1943 - United Airlines / Boeing Modification Center #10 - (Cheyenne Municipal Airport)
                Assigned: 28 May 1943 - 2nd AF / 390th BG / 571th BS - (Geiger AAF & Great Falls)
                                390th BG original aircraft
                Assigned: 30 June 1943 - 2nd AF / 21st BW / 390th BG / 571th BS - (Smoky Hill AAF)
                                                Staging Base
                                Assigned: 10 July 1943 - ATC / North Atlantic Wing - (Dow AAF)
                                                Port of embarkation
                Assigned: 12 July 1943 - 8th AF / 3rd AD / 13th CBW / 390th BG / 571th BS - (RAF Framlingham)
                                (Square-J) (FC * N / Short Stuff & Spirit of 76)
                                28 combat missions
                Assigned:  13 September 1943 - 8th AF / 3rd BD / 13th CBW / 390th BG / 571st BS - (RAF Framlingham)
                                MIA / Interned: Tuesday, 18 April 1944 @ 1740 hrs (Flak) - Bulltotfa Airfield, Malmö - Sweden (55°36'59"N / 13°10'12"E)
                                (Pilot: 1Lt Bernardo Procopio) - 10 Int (MACR 4012)
                                                8th AF mission 306 / 390th BG mission: 87 (Oranienburg, Germany - Luneburg Airfield)
                                                                #1 engine failure
                                                                Swedish report 92
                Assigned: June 1945 - 8th AF / 8th AFSC / 2 SAD - (RAF Little Staughton) - SOC.
Jump to:
© 2013 APG vNext Commercial Version 4.3