Kansan
Group Member
- Total Posts : 115
- Reward points : 1862
- Joined:
- Location: Pittsburg, KS
- Status: offline
Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
Here's a question for Steven Puhl. :-) A while back I was reading a 1956 book "The Story of Willow Run" (By Marion F. Wilson, Published by the University of Michigan Press in Ann Arbor, MI). This book mentioned and showed a few pictures of a B-24 simply named "Old 139" being manoeuvered into position somewhere outside the FO WR plant immediately post-war. I think the book said the plane was obtained by the Edsel Ford post of the American Legion in 1946. Sadly time and neglect did for the bird, like so many others. My question. All the photos published in the book are nose-on so it's impossible to ascertain what (if any) marking were being carried. What machine was it? Memorial B-24s are my 'thing' (to coin a phrase) and I'm having one of those "inquiring minds" moments. Any further information, Steven? Robert Smith 42-50535 "Joplin Jalopy" Blogger
|
WillowRun
AMIABLE HISTORIAN
- Total Posts : 1986
- Reward points : 18223
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
Robert, Good evening from AA! Based on the information I have, which is scattered at best, it would appear that "Old 139" was B-24M-20-FO, 44-51139. There were very few A/C's of each variant retained at FO WR, and toward the end of production, many were flown directly to the scrap yards, almost exclusively "M's" even though there were "war wearies" on the property as well. No A/C was retained as a "momento" to this "Arsenal of Democracy." In fact, Kaiser-Frazer took over the facility almost immediately, retooled it for peacetime production and returned to making cars, although the C-119 and C-123 transports were also assembled here. Over the years, attempts have been made by the Yankee Air Museum (YAM) to procure a Lib without much success. The best we could do was the restoration of a Privateer which has been restored and is a part of our "static display." About a year ago, I did receive a PM from a gentleman who recalled "having seen a Lib being moved to a park at the end of the war," but he had no recollection of any details. In trying to search this out, we've had no luck. Again, there are many "urban legends" about FO WR. Sorry I couldn't be of more help. I've searched both the net and elsewhere for a pic, but no luck.
post edited by WillowRun -
Best Regards! Steven Puhl Ford Willow Run Bomber Plant ( FO) Historian MODERATOR: http://www.armyairforces.com/Member: Yankee Air Museum Member: 8TH AF Historical Society Member: 2ND Air Division Historical Society
|
Kansan
Group Member
- Total Posts : 115
- Reward points : 1862
- Joined:
- Location: Pittsburg, KS
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
Steven, Thanks very much. You know how it is when you get curious about something. :-) I'm sure I scanned a couple of pictures from the book for reference purposes but I'm darned if I can find them now. If you haven't seen those pictures drop me a PM or something. I seem to remember reading it was "parked" on the site of an old orchard under an Apple tree (?!) near the Legion post. best wishes Robert
|
WillowRun
AMIABLE HISTORIAN
- Total Posts : 1986
- Reward points : 18223
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
"After flying A-20's in Italy in WWII, father went to work for United Air Lines, stationed at Willow Run (Ford Liberator factory) for three years in early sixties when it was the hub for commercial airlines - Detroit. There was a liberator parked by the side of a road for years on display back then, was vandalized, finally vanished." Robert, I found this quote in the sub-forum on "modeling" from August of 2007 in which Mark O'Boyle (an outstanding crafter/modeler) makes mention of the same A/C again with few details. Based on hearsay, some recollections and few records, it is probably "one-and-the-same." There is one other source whom I shall try to contact personally, and he may have some recollection having lived in the area.
Best Regards! Steven Puhl Ford Willow Run Bomber Plant ( FO) Historian MODERATOR: http://www.armyairforces.com/Member: Yankee Air Museum Member: 8TH AF Historical Society Member: 2ND Air Division Historical Society
|
Seabee1526
Squadron Member
- Total Posts : 13
- Reward points : 832
- Joined:
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
pieces/parts in somebody's pole barn.
|
WillowRun
AMIABLE HISTORIAN
- Total Posts : 1986
- Reward points : 18223
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
Seabee1526 pieces/parts in somebody's pole barn. Robert, Good morning! Would this be a question, assumption or a "part-of-the-puzzle" answer? There were (and still are) a lot of "urban legends" about WR. The legacy and the ghosts still permeate the "old plant" and its surroundings! I've posted an Ann Arbor News article link on page 7 or 8 in the Thread: History: The Willow Run Liberators in the the "Heavy and Very Heavy Bombers" sub-forum in which I debunked a few, but this one sort of hangs around. You might want to PM Mark O'Boyle, although I believe he still may not have located anything. Legend also has it that there was a "home movie" of it. I do have somewhere some old "xeroxed copies" of pics that I'll go thru as I do remember a pic of a Lib being moved "off site," but this well could have been for another reason. We'll keep searching!
Best Regards! Steven Puhl Ford Willow Run Bomber Plant ( FO) Historian MODERATOR: http://www.armyairforces.com/Member: Yankee Air Museum Member: 8TH AF Historical Society Member: 2ND Air Division Historical Society
|
WillowRun
AMIABLE HISTORIAN
- Total Posts : 1986
- Reward points : 18223
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
Robert, Good morning! I've found in my "box-of-stuff" the old, grainy xeroxed pics which I have scanned, but they are horrible, and it wasn't wortth the time to try and "clean-em-up." However, in the process I found their origin, and will be heading to one of the the three local university/public libraries to pull up the details and get more info on the A/C's. Now that I have a lead, I can go after the info. Looking at the pic, I can narrow down the variant, but as far a the location, no dice yet! One step at a time, and then, who knows, someone else may jump on with further info.
Best Regards! Steven Puhl Ford Willow Run Bomber Plant ( FO) Historian MODERATOR: http://www.armyairforces.com/Member: Yankee Air Museum Member: 8TH AF Historical Society Member: 2ND Air Division Historical Society
|
Seabee1526
Squadron Member
- Total Posts : 13
- Reward points : 832
- Joined:
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
I find it remarkable that there have been no leads on this. How can it just disappear?
|
WillowRun
AMIABLE HISTORIAN
- Total Posts : 1986
- Reward points : 18223
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
Seabee1526 I find it remarkable that there have been no leads on this. How can it just disappear? Robert, Today I talked with Warren Benjamin Kidder, author of Willow Run: Colossus of American Industry, about several issues, one of which was #139. So here is some updated info. Do not have an ID on the exact A/C, "but it did sit for a time near an apple orchard and "in front of a school on Michigan Avenue. It didn't last long though as it was sold for scrap." He couldn't recall exactly when.
Best Regards! Steven Puhl Ford Willow Run Bomber Plant ( FO) Historian MODERATOR: http://www.armyairforces.com/Member: Yankee Air Museum Member: 8TH AF Historical Society Member: 2ND Air Division Historical Society
|
Seabee1526
Squadron Member
- Total Posts : 13
- Reward points : 832
- Joined:
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
|
WillowRun
AMIABLE HISTORIAN
- Total Posts : 1986
- Reward points : 18223
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
Seabee1526 Bloody shame.... That it is!!! What is more intriguing is that in "snooping around," one finds that no one knows anything. It is hard to envision that something so large in the post WW II era just disappears. I've located the approximate spot, but no way can imagine the bird sitting there. Again this is speaking from a vantage point of more than 60 years.
Best Regards! Steven Puhl Ford Willow Run Bomber Plant ( FO) Historian MODERATOR: http://www.armyairforces.com/Member: Yankee Air Museum Member: 8TH AF Historical Society Member: 2ND Air Division Historical Society
|
WillowRun
AMIABLE HISTORIAN
- Total Posts : 1986
- Reward points : 18223
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
Good evening, Folks, from a snowy A2! I resurrected this "old Thread," have read all of the posts including my own with some bad assumption and am going to try piecing together a bit more information. I now have REread the book (I've posted a "review" on the "Book Corner" sub-forum) and am waiting on some responses (hopefully) from family members who actually lived in the Willow Run Village and may have good recollections of #139 or some actual data. In the meantime, I'll correct some of the errors that I may have generated, as well as try to narrow down the search for which FO WR bird it was. Maybe this will generate some more leads. Here are the FO WR birds that I think are possibilities, based on the poor frontal or slightl angled pix which DO NOT give any idea of S/N, but do allow a view of the navigator's observation window (NOW), the NMF and nose configuration. Based on information from the b24bestwb.com reserch Site, I've also made some assumptions from that data. Hopefully, we can try and further clarify Robert's question: "All the photos published in the book are nose-on so it's impossible to ascertain what (if any) marking were being carried. What machine was it?" Here are possibilites of different A/Cs: 1. B-24H-25-FO, 42-95139: Correct NOW, listed only as crashed in the Netherlands and then RESTORED. A possibility based on physical characteristics but no further info. 2. B-24H-10-FO, 42-52139: No Info, but would have had correct NOW but would NOT have been a NMF and it would have been highly unlikely that it was stripped of its OD finish for the rest of its service. A possibility but not too probable. 3. B-24L-1-FO, 44-49139: Would have the correct NOW and NMF, but have found NO info on it WHICH makes this a possibility, as the records for the plane based on the book are "vague at that." 4. B-24M-10-FO, 44-51139: NO possibilty (this is the one I had listed in post #2)... wrong NOW and it was scrapped at Kingman, AZ in 1945 and therefore would not have been available. Here is what is FACTUALLY known from the book: 1. The War Department had #139 flown to the Willow Run Airport on 2.25.46. 2. Dedicated: Sunday, 5.26.46 with Mr. and Mrs. Henry Ford present. 3. Was located on Michigan Avenue at Spencer Road uin an apple orchard across the street from the VFW Hall. 4. Old #139 was finally dismantled and taken away by a scrap company in 1950. By this time, however, she had been vandalized, neglected, and become the residence of various birds and land creatures. She was meant to be free and in the air, not neglected on the ground. So, it still rests to determine "who she was...."
Attached Image(s)
Best Regards! Steven Puhl Ford Willow Run Bomber Plant ( FO) Historian MODERATOR: http://www.armyairforces.com/Member: Yankee Air Museum Member: 8TH AF Historical Society Member: 2ND Air Division Historical Society
|
RSwank
Division Member
- Total Posts : 1993
- Reward points : 6216
- Joined:
- Location: Holland, MI USA
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
|
25Kingman49
Wing Member
- Total Posts : 744
- Reward points : 1890
- Joined:
- Location: Utah
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
Steven, Not too much help, but here is a photo of #139 upon arrival at the airport with a slightly more side view of the aircraft, still can’t see more identification. From http://ypsigleanings.aadl.org/taxonomy/term/568 A B24 comes home to Willow Run Airport in February 1946, following completion of its World War II duties. The crew of #139 is welcomed by the members of the Edsel Ford American Legion. Read more about Ypsilanti History in Photographs in Ypsilanti Gleanings. Still digging… Sorry same photo dollar late and 5 minuts short Scott
Attached Image(s)
|
25Kingman49
Wing Member
- Total Posts : 744
- Reward points : 1890
- Joined:
- Location: Utah
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
Here’s a little more info on the disposition and where scrapped: Michael Luther Post subject: Posted: Thu Nov 10, 2005 3:51 am Location: Belleville, Michigan B-24 #139 was scraped by a scrap Co. gust across the street from where the bomber was on display. about 10 years ago the scrappers surplus store was still open, with the owner still alive/running it. The owner was very informative, and my dad and myself were able to find a lot of the B-24 parts still, along with other aircraft the man had scrapped. He had his Gov bid papers still, that showed he won the bid/scrapped- many CG-4s, B-36s and others. He still had 2 L-5s and all the B-24 turrets, that were just bought before we got there. _________________ Michael Luther Yankee Air Museum's Air Show Director THUNDER OVER MICHIGAN Source: http://www.warbirdinformationexchange.org/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?p=45745 Scott
|
WillowRun
AMIABLE HISTORIAN
- Total Posts : 1986
- Reward points : 18223
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
Thank you Rolland and Scott for the assistance, albeit the futilty as this one is tough! I've noticed that "official records" are lacking and then when something pops up, critical info like a S/N are not available. I was hoping that the S/N would have been visible on the inside right rudder. Also notice that the .50 cals had alread been removed (protocol) before being flown to WR. I'm still hoping that someone from the community here may still have info. As I said in Post #12, it would be great if one of the listed S/Ns would be it. At least we are pretty confident that its parts aren't stored in someones pole barn around here! Ha!
Best Regards! Steven Puhl Ford Willow Run Bomber Plant ( FO) Historian MODERATOR: http://www.armyairforces.com/Member: Yankee Air Museum Member: 8TH AF Historical Society Member: 2ND Air Division Historical Society
|
Tom22
Group Member
- Total Posts : 163
- Reward points : 9165
- Joined:
- Status: offline
|
WillowRun
AMIABLE HISTORIAN
- Total Posts : 1986
- Reward points : 18223
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
Tom, Your post made me want to delete my post #12 ENTIRELY! I must have been having a TRULY SERIOUS SENIOR moment (or longer period) as I pulled that information (or lack-of) together. Truth be said, the large numbers really didn't have mch to do in most cases with the S/Ns (T/Ns). Somewhere in the "depths-of-this-Site" there is a post by Al Blue about just such numbers. I remember him having attached it to another Thread. I haven't had time to locate it yet, but I'm sure it's about "Training and/or Ferrying ships!" That might be another lead on this "cold case." BTW, love the pix of the "N"s you posted!
post edited by WillowRun -
Best Regards! Steven Puhl Ford Willow Run Bomber Plant ( FO) Historian MODERATOR: http://www.armyairforces.com/Member: Yankee Air Museum Member: 8TH AF Historical Society Member: 2ND Air Division Historical Society
|
25Kingman49
Wing Member
- Total Posts : 744
- Reward points : 1890
- Joined:
- Location: Utah
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
|
25Kingman49
Wing Member
- Total Posts : 744
- Reward points : 1890
- Joined:
- Location: Utah
- Status: offline
Re:Willow Run Gate Guardian - "Old 139"
(permalink)
|